The Best Underwear Subscriptions For Every Budget

Best Overall: Underclub

Sign Up Now

Why We Chose It: The diverse and wide selection of brands and styles means there are options for every kind of customer. 

What We Like: 

• Large number of styles
• A detailed questionnaire to curate offerings
• A wide range of designers

What We Don’t Like: 

• Price may be too steep for some
• You don’t get to select your preferred brand

The motto for Underclub is all about bringing you “designer-to-door underwear.” Meaning, instead of pushing its own brand, the company offers selections from ones you already love like Cosabella, Natori, and DKNY.

Subscribers can choose from two different plans: The Luxe is roughly $35 per month for two pairs or about $21 per month for one and includes styles that retail between approximately $28 to $55 or more. For a little less, there’s the Signature which comes in at around $28 per month for two pairs and about $15 for one and includes styles that retail between about $18 to $25. 

As far as styles go, options run the gamut (and come in sizes ranging from XS to 4XL). A detailed questionnaire allows members to curate their box based on color preference (lights, nudes, neons), prints (florals, stripes, none at all), and amount of coverage (from thong to boyshort). There’s also a chance to mention any personal details or gripes that might help in the selection process. Don’t be afraid to take advantage of this particular section: The more vocal you are, the better the curation.

Best Budget: BootayBag

Sign Up Now

Why We Choose It: If you don’t care about filling your drawer with fancy lingerie, BootayBag provides everyday options that still manage to be cute and trendy. 

What We Like: 

• On-trend prints
• Option for add-ons
• Reasonable prices

What We Don’t Like: 

• Not much variety in the monthly selections
• Only two underwear styles: non-thong or thong

BootayBag is perfect for the athletic type or those who don’t want to put too much thought into their undergarments—or, as the website states, women “who hate digging through mall sale bins for their undies.” The monthly subscription costs $15 per month for one pair, $18 per month for two pairs, or $28 per month for four. There’s also an option for add-ons, such as joggers, bralettes, lounge wear, and casual dresses, all ranging in price.

The style options are sparse and simple (non-thong or thong) but the prints are plenty. If you're not into surprises, the brand provides a sneak peek into what you can expect in your monthly bag on Instagram which is also where you can vote on preferred future prints and give suggestions.

Best Variety: Savage x Fenty

Sign Up Now

Why We Chose It: As if the Rihanna endorsement wasn’t enough, Savage X Fenty items work for the laid-back underwear fan, as well as the maximalist one. Plus, the VIP membership comes with a number of perks. 

What We Like: 

• Variety of styles, fabrics, and sizes
• Added perks (XTRA VIP Offers)
• You can opt-out each month

What We Don’t Like: 

• Users have complained about some confusion surrounding the membership
• The price can be steep
• You have to select your own pieces every month

Rihanna’s Savage X Fenty has been endorsed and flaunted by Megan Thee Stallion, Normani, the Hadid sisters, and so many more (including, of course, the bad gal herself). If you, too, want to feel like a part of Rih’s cool club, sign up for the brand’s XTRA VIP Membership program which gives members access to free shipping and returns, discounted styles, exclusive sets, and early access to new drops. 

The program can be a little confusing so bear with us: For about $50 per month, you get the aforementioned perks, as well as a credit for the same amount that you can spend on purchases (which must be used in full in order to be redeemed) or saved for the future as credits (which never expire). If you don’t want the credits (or to buy anything that month), you can skip by the 5th of each month and you won’t be charged.

The catch here is that you have to search for and select your preferred bra, underwear, or whatever else you choose. This can be great if you’re picky about your lingerie, or it can be a hassle if you’d prefer to have the selection process handled by someone else. The good thing is there’s plenty of sensual, unique, and stylish pieces to choose from.

Best Eco-Conscious: MeUndies

Sign Up Now

Why We Choose It: We love MeUndies because it provides basics that are both sustainable and comfortable. 

What We Like: 

• The sustainable, biodegradable fabric
• Options for both men and women
• You can choose the exact pair you want, down to style, fit, and design

What We Don’t Like: 

• Print options can skew childish or boring compared to others
• No surprise element

Though you’re probably not throwing out underwear with the frequency that you do, say, a used (and recyclable) bottle of face wash, as with a lot of purchases, an eco-friendly approach can only benefit our environment.

MeUndies managed to create underwear for both men and women that are not only incredibly soft but biodegradable, as well. It’s thanks to a fabric called MicroModal, which, as the website outlines, is created by turning beechwood into a pulp, then extracting the fibers that are spun into yarn. It's pretty high-tech for underwear and impressive, too.

For about $16-$18 a month you can select your own style, fit, and design (some prints include panda bears, a space theme, and pot leaves…who said basics have to be boring?), and you can switch things up every month while, over time, building a collection you enjoy.